Movie Review: The Great Wall 长城


The Great Wall was recently released in China with much hype. Directed by the Zhang Yimou (director of Raise the Red Lantern, among many other critically-acclaimed films as well as the famed opening ceremony of the 2008 Beijing Olympics), and starring Matt Damon, it is bilingual and the first truly American and Chinese coproduction. Suffice to say, expectations were high.

Unfortunately, perhaps due to the high expectations, the film has already been poorly received and critically panned in China. However, for a causal audience member not steeped in fifth-generation Chinese cinema film buff lore, it can still make for an enjoyable romp. If one just forgets to consider the tide of Hollywood pandering to China, not to mention ignoring problematic ‘white savior’ tropes, it is possible to see The Great Wall as a decent and fun film.

Taken for what it is, Zhang’s latest does succeed at being an exciting fantasy adventure about Western explorers fighting monsters in an ancient Chinese setting. Suspension of disbelief always required, the story opens with a couple of horse-riding mercenaries seeking mysterious explosive black powder. Eventually they make it to the Great Wall, where they meet Damon’s love interest Commander Lin played by Jing Tian.

Matt Damon more or less pulls off the medieval accent passably, and his costar Game of Thrones’ Pedro Pascal is excellent and usually outshines Damon in scenes featuring both of them. The pair of warriors have good chemistry as buddy action films go, although with a somewhat predictable character arc as they break up and get back together. Pascal’s Hispanic heritage is used for corny effect (although the actor is from Chile, he plays a Spaniard), complete with a completely unnecessary “bullfighting” scene.

Willem Dafoe is also utilized well as a sniveling fellow Westerner. Andy Lau’s grizzled military officer rounds out the cast as the requisite token Chinese star, but he is often left behind by the star power of the rest of the cast.

The plot moves quickly and doesn’t wait long to jump into Peter Jackson-style tower sieges. The monsters are called Taotie and the special effects are indeed Hollywood level, although at this point in cinema history it’s long since past groundbreaking to see mass hordes of demons in epically intricate battles. When the scenes go smaller scale into warriors battle monsters individually, the carefully honed craft of Chinese wushu-style film proves to be more engaging than the indulgences of high-end Hollywood CGI war.

As the plot goes, there are some logistics that make little sense. The moral lessons of trust and loyalty are heavy handed. The origin story of the monsters didn’t seem to have much thought at all behind it, although one does suppose that it’s a fantasy universe so why not. And in particular, the color-coded uniforms for the Chinese army is especially cheesey and reminiscent of those childish superheroes the Power Rangers. The climatic final battle in the capital city does make up for much of the flaws of the film, but overall The Great Wall is not meant to be taken so seriously in the first place.

Whether or not Zhang Yimou has “sold out” as some accuse, The Great Wall was never meant to be his finest work. It probably won’t succeed as a breakout introduction of Chinese cinema for Western audiences, but of those who do watch the film it’s definitely worth taking the time to see what all the fuss has been about.

This reviewer recommends low expectations. Don’t think too much, and just enjoy it for what it is: A fun, dumb Hollywood fantasy movie which just happens to take place in China.

The Great Wall will be released in America on February 17th.


11 thoughts on “Movie Review: The Great Wall 长城

  1. Thanks for the review. I am wondering whether to watch it here in Germany or not. I think it will launch in a few weeks here.
    What speaks against watching it is that there is no real thought about the monsters / their origin. Such things are always what helps with the immersion and is one of the main “Needs to be in the book/ movie” in my opinion. All little details are creating a true epic tale…


  2. I also watched it the other day. I’d heard about the bad reviews so I went with low expectations. But I also knew what I was going to see: a pop corn blockbuster. So I enjoyed it for what it was (and I liked the colourful uniforms that totally looked like Chinese RPG games hahaha). I don’t even think it’s the worst Zhang Yimou movie. I have watched most of his films and the guy always does what he wants and is not afraid to change styles.

    From his newer movies, check “Coming home” from a couple of years ago. It has a similar feel to his old movies (like Ju Dou and Raise the red lantern, my favourites).

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: My review of the film The Great Wall • Zhi Chinese

  4. Thank you for the review. I like your comment: to take it as what it is. Most Chinese audience want too much from Zhang, which is not fair. One small thing : In this sentence “…be more engaging than than the indulgences of high-end Hollywood CGI war.” It seems that you need to get rid of one “than”

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Pingback: The Great Wall-Not Trump's Version - Unhealed WoundUnhealed Wound

  6. I remember hearing about this movie, but it seemed to disappear after a while. Now I know why – it’s just ok. Sounds like it’s a movie that could have been interesting, but didn’t work out after all.


Leave a Reply Ya

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.